I always like doing this just to try and keep things in perspective: http://www.capgeek.com/comparables/?player_id=1110&year_id=2014 Do a sort by age and then look at length. I don't think its fair to compare a Carle to a MacDonald. MacDonald has a much better sense in the d-zone and makes smart break out plays. He will never be a 30 point guy, but his hits (while not bruising, still there) and his blocks balance out what a Carle brings you. I think its about 250k too much, but I am okay with that. Look at the list of others there with 6 years that are at, slightly below, or slightly higher.